• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
American Dreaming

American Dreaming

Ideals and Realities of the American Dream

  • Home
  • Human Spirit
  • Perspective
  • Economics
  • Science & Tech
  • Fulfilling the Dream

The Space Shuttle was a Failure

2019-11-20 by Peter Kosen

The loss of both the Challenger and the Columbia were tragedies. But they were both just part of a much greater failure. It’s not a popular thing to say. And, to some people it seems unpatriotic. Especially space geeks and other technology enthusiasts who grew up during the Apollo program and caught the bug of excitement over the development of space flight don’t like anyone to say it. And they like to point to the many exciting space flights, the many landings of a reusable aerospace plane, and the many really great pieces of advanced technology that it launched into orbit, including the assembly of the International Space Station.

But:

The Space Shuttle was totally and fundamentally a complete, unmitigated failure from the very beginning.

Because it wasn’t designed by NASA engineers who were trying to make the best space plane ever.

It was designed by the U.S. Congress.

THIS IS A STUB ARTICLE WHICH WILL EXPAND ON THE FOLLOWING TOPICS:

The Space Shuttle had one and only one function: It was a delivery truck to earth orbit.

As such, it had one and only one goal: To be a cheap and reusable vehicle.

It was not reusable. (Need to expand on this because people argue against it all the time.) It had to be basically rebuilt every time it was launched.

It was not and was never intended to be an exploratory vehicle. It could not go anywhere besides low earth orbit because it was too heavy and wings are impractical for going anywhere else. It was a marvelous engineering accomplishment. But it was not a leap in technology.

They had already done development on a better, more reusable system. (Describe the Dyna-Soar.)

It was stupid to have the primary taxi for people also be the primary booster for cargo.

It was terribly small and weak because it was so awfully big and heavy.

The military introduced requirements, part of which they never used.

It was dangerous. Stupid side boosters assembled in segments should never have been used on a vehicle to launch humans.

The tiles were a band aid solution. The foam was a band aid solution. And putting the crew vehicle behind the foam was unnecessary.

The International Space Station was started in 1998 and was assembled with the help of the Shuttle over a nearly fifteen year period at the expense of $150 billion. This included a total of $50 billion for 36 separate shuttle flights to carry up pieces and assemble it.

If just 5 more Saturn V moon rockets had been produced when it was in production after the Apollo program, the entire space station could have been hefted into orbit with just 5 launches. It would have been bigger. It wouldn’t have been in so many separate, small pieces. And each launch cost less than $1 billion.

The space station could have been a 100% United States venture completed in the mid-1970s instead of a 15 year international project started 20 years after it should have been complete.

Thanks, Congress. It’s thanks to the U.S. government’s inability to actually manage anything constructive that we’re still just going around in circles (116,178 orbits as of today) in low earth orbit instead of actually exploring anything like they said we would.

Posted Under: Science & Technology

Primary Sidebar

Related Articles

The Human Spirit

Here, I want to present a baseline for what we mean by … [Read More...] about The Human Spirit

Castles on the Hill

There is a prejudice in the world today that is not quite … [Read More...] about Castles on the Hill

Collaborators in this Site

The thoughts, principles, histories, and opinions … [Read More...] about Collaborators in this Site

The Percent Wealth Tax Heist

Let’s just start right in on the obvious: First of all, … [Read More...] about The Percent Wealth Tax Heist

The Space Shuttle was a Failure

The loss of both the Challenger and the Columbia … [Read More...] about The Space Shuttle was a Failure

Civil Asset Forfeiture

This is the story of a good government gone bad. … [Read More...] about Civil Asset Forfeiture

Who’s going to invade the United States?

The purpose of this article is to put into … [Read More...] about Who’s going to invade the United States?

A Proper Welfare System

When someone who grew up in the Soviet Union tells you that … [Read More...] about A Proper Welfare System

The Sunrise Story

How much are life experiences worth? What, exactly, are … [Read More...] about The Sunrise Story

Was it Aliens?

Some people look at the tech explosion of the 20th century … [Read More...] about Was it Aliens?

Personal Adventures

This will be an index page to various personal stories … [Read More...] about Personal Adventures

Privilege will always exist & it is immoral to try to eliminate it.

How’s that for a provocative, click bait title? I’m looking … [Read More...] about Privilege will always exist & it is immoral to try to eliminate it.

David and Goliath – the Real Story

A lesson in perspective and touching base with … [Read More...] about David and Goliath – the Real Story

Why should we allow exploration of space instead of fixing poverty on Earth?

Why do we not push for getting everyone everywhere all on … [Read More...] about Why should we allow exploration of space instead of fixing poverty on Earth?

Without Regard to Race, Religion, Sex, etc.

Everyone has seen the phrase above, or some variation of … [Read More...] about Without Regard to Race, Religion, Sex, etc.

Value and Price

Sometimes it seems as though the concept of “value” is … [Read More...] about Value and Price

The Long View

I don't want to show that much profit in this quarter.  … [Read More...] about The Long View

What is the American Dream?

For some people, the American Dream may be a comfortable … [Read More...] about What is the American Dream?

White Nationalists

Can we please just treat these people as they deserve to be … [Read More...] about White Nationalists

I’m not going to Mars. (But maybe you can)

Yes, we’ll deal with both of the statements in the title … [Read More...] about I’m not going to Mars. (But maybe you can)

Footer

PROMOTING THE REALIZATION OF THE FULL POTENTIAL OF THE HUMAN SPIRIT

  • We hold these truths to be self-evident: That all men are created equal; That they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights; That among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness;
  • Without Regard to Race, Color, Religion, Sex, National Origin or other Personal Characteristics;
  • Dismissing “Liberal/Conservative” & “Right/Left” and other shallow tribalistic labels in favor of meaningful dialog on each issue that affects our society;
  • And promoting an environment of freedom and opportunity that maximizes the full expression of each individual Human Spirit.

Recent

  • The Sunrise Story
  • Personal Adventures
  • We Should be Going Nuclear
  • I’m not going to Mars. (But maybe you can)
  • Why should we allow exploration of space instead of fixing poverty on Earth?

Search

Copyright © 2023 · American Dreaming